Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Seal's avatar

I'm not convinced that someone who claims they've been opposing the Iranian Revolution for "47 years" - in other words, since the overthrow of the Shah - was ever a leftist. Did Tudeh not support the 1979 Revolution? Anyone who instantly heel-turned away from the Revolution as soon as it happened is probably a monarchist.

Nick's avatar

Another useful report from Ryan Grim.

Of course the interview is of just one person, with a definite point of view and political opinion; but it's better than nothing.

My $0.02 is: a theocracy is bad, countries should have secular governments; but Iran's is very far from the worst. There is religious freedom in Iran - several active synagogues in Teheran, active Christian churches, a Christian cathedral in Isfahan, an active Zoroastrian community in Yazd, etc. The theocracy imposes restrictions: no alcohol, women have to wear headscarves, no short sleeves or shorts (both men and women). But the protests aren't about that. They're about the bad state of the economy, which really isn't the regime's fault, it's the result of US-imposed sanctions. Replacing the theocracy with a secular govt would not change that.

13 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?